Sunday, August 30, 2009
A Complicated Life
(From CBS2School)
Like Senator Ted Kennedy, representative democracy has led a complicated American life.
Elected to the U.S. Senate in 1962, Kennedy became the model for what some of our Constitutional Framers envisioned as the best way to serve the Republic. But others contend that this unbeatable incumbent reflected a darker side of our democracy when entrenched politicians stay in power for decades.
While serving as lawmakers, elected representatives must constantly weigh two sides when casting each of their legislative votes.
On one side, the delegates attempt to vote identical to popular will.
These representatives keep a close watch on opinion polls and will often consult their constituents for guidance as to the stance that a majority of voters.
Critics contend that the popular democracy which flavors the delegate approach can water down bold initiatives and give too much power to the masses.
The delegate approach to representation can also result in a legislator who waivers in between two ideological camps. American popular opinion often sits on the fence between ideological extremes, and representatives voting with the delegate approach often gain the reputations of being politically independent.
Ted Kennedy was no delegate.
Kennedy was a classic example of a legislator who votes as a trustee.
He was one of 23 Senators who voted against the war in Iraq when nearly 70% of Americans favored war. He consistently used this trustee approach to vote his conscience, not to cater to public will.
Kennedy often spoke about working for the common good when it came to expanding the role of the federal government into education and healthcare. And he advocated for the marginalized in pushing for expanded protections of ethnic minorities and homosexuals.
Some of our Framers might have seen Ted Kennedy as their model of legislator who could avoid voting with special interests and vote for the common good. But conservatives in Massachusetts who opposed his ideas, would likely say that Kennedy’s approach left them without a voice in the Senate since 1962.
Regardless, it’s important to remember Kennedy apart from his brothers and his prominent political family.
Kennedy should also be remembered as another one of the prolific members of Congress from Massachusetts. And like John Adams, John Quincy Adams and Daniel Webster, Kennedy’s public service offers much for us to reflect about the complexities of our Republic.
http://www.govtrack.us/congress/person.xpd?id=300059
Monday, August 24, 2009
Jihad vs. McWorld
http://www.theatlantic.com/doc/199203/barber
Wednesday, August 12, 2009
Milton Gladly
Fox News and other like-minded conservative outlets use the rowdy footage to exaggerate animosity toward Obama’s health care policy.
CNN and other more Obama-friendly media use the Town Hall outbursts to suggest a right wing conspiracy has been organized. Republicans, they claim, orchestrate Astroturf hostility in desperation before facing another defeat to a popular president.

Wonderfully for us we have both options to consider. It has not always been so.
Freedom of speech has faced great opposition throughout history. One of its greatest defenders, however, was English polemicist and poet John Milton (1608-1674). Areopagitica, published in 1644, was Milton’s most ardent defense against the tyranny of censorship and government-controlled speech. In particular Milton was speaking out against Parliament’s Licensing Order of 1643. Despite his loyalty to Parliament during the English civil war, Milton disagreed with their new found power of censoring the written word. Protecting it against dissent never protects truth. He wrote:
“Though all the winds of doctrine were let loose to play upon the earth, so Truth be in the field, we do injuriously by licensing and prohibiting to misdoubt her strength. Let her and Falsehood grapple; who ever knew Truth put to the worse, in a free and open encounter.”
Unfettered free speech was not Milton’s end game. Even Milton understood the need for limits. Free speech to Milton did not give license to the inane or foolish. He encouraged some level prudence.
What to do then about these rowdy and raucous Town Hall meetings?
A recent TIME magazine article suggested that the French have learned to adopt a more modest attitude when it comes to swim attire or the lack there of. Traditional two-piece bikinis have replaced the more revealing and revered topless bathing. The French word for this new prim attitude is pudique.
Before our own cultural Star Chamber rewrites the rules for political speech, perhaps a little pudique here in America would help the cause. Recognizing a respectful etiquette when exercising our free speech may go along way in helping to preserve it. When crossing into the busy streets of political discourse adhering to the adage “stop, look and listen” may help advance the truth.
After all, as former Chief Justice Warren E. Burger once stated, “Free speech carries with it some freedom to listen.”
Milton would have gladly agreed and so should we.
_________________
Health Care Town Hall Anger Rages On
Out on the health care firing line, senators and members of Congress continued to get battered by constituents angry over President Barack Obama’s reform plan Wednesday — with voters raising questions about everything from assisted suicide to coverage for illegal immigrants.
Lawmakers insisted over and over that the bills in Congress would cover neither — but their answers did nothing to tamp down the anger from Afton, Iowa, to Hagerstown, Md., to Rocky Mount, N.C.
In Iowa, a self-described “dumb southern Iowa redneck” told Republican Sen. Chuck Grassley, “I see nowhere in the Constitution where health care is a right. ... I want to hear it from Obama, I want to hear it from Pelosi, about how this is about ‘We the people.’“
Tuesday, August 11, 2009
Eunice Kennedy Shriver transformed attitudes, transcended politics
The health care debate today makes one wonder if politicians can transform attitudes.The Kennedy Family is one of America's foremost political families, but it may have been the sister of JFK, Bobby and Teddy that had the most influence on changing attitudes in a way that transcends politics. Eunice Kennedy Shriver, founder of Special Olympics, has passed away.
No one paid attention to people with intellectual disabilities before EKS began her mission that became a movement to bring joy, dignity and empowerment to people with intellectual disabilities. Before she pushed her brother JFK to start the Presidential Commission on Mental Retardation, the word "retard" was a commonplace pejorative.
EKS helped us change our attitudes about what's possible. The Special Olympics needed government support. Today it is a worldwide movement that brings joy, dignity and empowerment to people with intellectual disabilities.
Special Olympics chronicles EKS life with tributes here: //www.eunicekennedyshriver.org/
And while some political pundits raised the question of who will be the most influential Kennedy, in light of cancer-striken Senator Ted Kennedy's career fight for universal health care, one should not forget the mission Eunice Kennedy Shriver accomplished over a life that transcended politics and transformed American attitudes.
Thursday, July 16, 2009
Poltics trumps governing in State's stopgap budget
While mortified citizens called for more government oversight in light of the Burr Oak Cemetery Crime Scene, lawmakers in Springfield finally passed a stop-gap budget that allowed the State government to continue to (dis) function. Blago is gone, but one wonders when we will see the courage to govern.
Both the Illinois House and Senate passed bills that circumvent a revenue raising income tax hike by borrowing (obviously needed, but also obviously a perceived political death wish for lawmakers) $3.5 billion from state pensions and putting off billions more in unpaid bills to state vendors until next year.
The spending plan will also include significant cuts to state spending (at Gov. Quinn's discretion), including to third party social service providers. It's unclear exactly how large a cut they will see to their FY 2009 funding levels, but the Tribune publishes one estimate:
The Illinois Budget battle is a a case study of what is going on around the country. As Newsweek columnist Robert Samuelson writes:
"We face an unprecedented collision between Americans' desire for more government services and there almost unwillingness to be taxed."
www.realclearpolitics.com/articles/2009/07/13/the_consequences_of_big_government.html
The National Health Care Debate is front-and-center in this debate, with several other twists I will blog later about later this week. Do we want more government services....even if we have to pay for them? The issue here for you as Illinois citizens is do you want your government to govern -- even if it means telling you tough news, like an income tax hike. Or do we elect them to play politics -- saying, not doing, what we want to hear.
By the way, what do you think about the Senate (roll call?) vote. Sen. Ricky Hendon calls the vote after Senate President John Cullerton's comments.
Tuesday, July 14, 2009
Inside Baseball: Senate Judiciary Confirmation Hearing's All-Star Gamesmanship
Inside Baseball -- The expression "inside baseball" is sometimes used as a metaphor for details or minutia of a subject so detailed that they generally are not well known by outsiders. An example may be a film critic's review of a movie using insider jargon, information, or understanding of which regular movie goers would have little knowledge. Citing the director's previous themes expressed in his/her movies in relation to the one being reviewed because of the director's fascination with X-school of film making, etc., would be considered an example of "inside baseball".Another example could be seen when looking in on the coverage of the Senate Confirmation Hearings of Judge Sonia Sotomayor, nominated to be the next Supreme Court Justice. Judge Sotomayor would be just the third woman on the High Court, and first Latino -- or Latina. Coverage was dominated by the Judge's famous, or imfamous "Wise Latina," quote. Or her childhood. Little was talked about Constitutional interpretation. I guess that type of Inside Baseball Stuff is appropirate on the night of Major League Baseball's Mid-Summer Classic.
CBS 2 School gives this interesting take:
Busch Stadium in St. Louis will host the 80th Mid-Summer classic. The major league baseball All-Star game is one of the few of its kind that fans actually watch enthusiastically. At stake is home field advantage for this year’s World Series. More importantly baseball’s greats, as determined by the fans, will compete against each other in America’s game. There is no other game like it.
The first all-star game was played in old Comiskey Park in Chicago in 1933. Babe Ruth dazzled the 49,000 paid customers by hitting a home run in the 3rd to lead the American League to its first victory.
To date, the National League leads the series with 40 wins. The American League has won 37 and there have been 2 ties. The longest game occurred last year with the American League winning in 15 innings. The game took 4 hours and 50 minutes to play.
A total of 668 runs have been scored; the National League has scored 333 and the American League 335.
In 1945 the game was not played due to World War 2. Between 1959 and 1962 there were two all-star games played each year.
Derek Jeter leads all Mid-Summer classic players with a batting average of .475. Willie Mays, Hank Aaron and Stan Musial each played in 24 games. Roger Clemens leads all pitchers with 10 appearances.
The All-Star game is one of our rites of summer. (Inside Baseball Stuff)
Yet there is another game this week with all-star proportions. This week the nomination of Sonia Sotomayor to fill David Souter’s Supreme Court vacancy will be considered by the Senate Judiciary Committee. It is the closest thing our government has to an all-star game.
Confirmation hearings bring all three branches of government into play. Barack Obama, the chief executive nominates. The Senate, representing the legislative branch, confirms under the authority of its “advice and consent” power found in Article Two of the U.S. Constitution. The end result is a full court made up of 9 Supreme Court justices whose charge is to interpret our laws.
If confirmed, Sonia Sotomayor will be our 111th Supreme Court justice. If successful, she will be confirmed by the 111th Congress.
Throughout our history 30 nominations have failed; 8 withdrawn, 12 rejected, 4 postponed and 6 received no action.
The Senate Judiciary Committee, responsible for the first round of enquiry, is filled with a Who’s Who of today’s U.S. Senate. The only personality missing, and we will miss him, is Joe Biden who has opted for a higher calling.
Democrats fill 12 of the 19 seats. Short-tempered Patrick Leahy Chairs the Committee. This will be his first confirmation hearing to grandstand. It will be noteworthy to watch the recently-switched-to-Democrat Arlen Specter, one-time Republican Chair, sitting at the end of the table next to the Party’s most recent addition Al Franken.
Republicans will try to steal some of the attention at this mid-summer classic. This game is never dull. With 60 Democratic Senators able to block any filibuster attempt, the 111th Justice will be Sonia Sotomayor.
You can count on it.
The Politico's Glenn Thrush gives us this program, if you will, of what to watch during the confirmation hearings:
Sonia Sotomayor still speaks with her elderly mom, who’s retired in Florida, “every day.”
She’s a “doting” aunt to three of her brother’s children and an “attentive godmother to five more.”
And did you know she was a “fearless and effective prosecutor” and anti-child-pornography crusader widely credited “with saving baseball”?
These biographical gems come from the official, 200-plus-page White House playbook distributed to Senate Judiciary Committee Democrats tasked with defending President Barack Obama’s SCOTUS nominee during this week’s confirmation hearings.
Republicans, for their part, concede they are too outnumbered in the Senate (60 Democrats to 40 Republicans) and the Judiciary Committee (12 to 7) to stop the nomination.
But they’ll try — and here are six things to watch as they do:
Read more: http://www.politico.com/news/stories/0709/24864.html#ixzz0LGrdInim&C
We will learn about Judical Activism and Strict Constructionalism during the fall. But what about Judicial Empathy? More Senators stated, without questioning, a concern of a new emerging empathy standard. More Inside Baseball stuff.
At the Sotomayor hearing, Sen. Jon Kyl (R-Ariz.) said, “Unfortunately, a very important person has decided it's time for a change, time for a new kind of judge, one who will apply a different standard of judging, including employment
Of course, Republican worries about the “Obama standard” only go so far. It was also Graham who told Sotomayor, “Unless you have a complete meltdown, you’re going to get confirmed.”
Thursday, June 25, 2009
Comparative Politics of Protest: China lacks Rule of Law 20 years after Tiananmen Square

Earlier this summer, before the heat was turned on the non-democratic Islamic Republic of Iran, the Chinese government kept tabs on ceremonies aimed at at recognizing the 20th anniversary the student-led Tiananmen Square of 1989.
What can the Chinese Case Study of protest tell us as we try to predict the future in Iran? And what does it tell us about the lack of Rule of Law in authoritarian -- even if supposedly democratically elected -- regimes?
Here are a couple of pieces of interest out of China. Can you draw compariso
ns to events in Iran?From Newsweek's June 15 issue:
China's Ghost Writer
In designing the "bird's nest" Olympic stadium, Chinese artist Ai Weiwei helped create an architectura
l icon for China. Yet now he's living under police surveillance. His crime? Running a blog that lists the names of kids who died in poorly built schools in the 2008 Sichuan earthquake. In the crackdown ahead of last week's Tiananmen Square anniversary, China's censors deleted Ai's blog without explanation. "The state tried so hard to make [the victims] vanish," says Ai. He began his list in March, frustrated by government inaction. By May he'd gathered 5,010 names and enough publicity to prod the government to compile its own tally of the dead. But Ai says, "You cannot just give us numbers." Now the blog has been wiped from servers, and Ai could face arrest, though he says he's "ready" for that. And while Beijing may have squashed one digital irritant, with Internet use doubling annually, the virtual realm could prove too vast and fast for China to control.________________
From the June 3, Huffington Post:
Tiananmen Square: Foreign Reporters Barred By China On Eve Of Anniversary
BEIJING — A massive police presense ringed China's iconic Tiananmen Square on Thursday, the 20th anniversary of the bloody crackdown on pro-democracy activists, as the government continued an overwhelming drive to muzzle dissent and block commemorations.An exiled protest leader _ famous for publicly haranguing one of China's top leaders 20 years ago _ was also blocked from returning home to confront officials over what he called the "June 4 massacre."
Foreign journalists were barred from the vast square as uniformed and plainclothes police stood guard across the vast plaza that was the epicenter of the student-led movement that was crushed by the military on the night of June 3-4, 1989.
Security officials checking passports also blocked foreign TV camera operators and photographers from entering covering the raising of China's national flag, which happens at dawn every day. Plain clothes officers aggressively confronted journalists on the streets surrounding the square, cursing and threatening violence against them.
The heavy security moves come after government censors shut down social networking and image-sharing Web sites such as Twitter and Flickr, blacked out CNN when it airs stories on Tiananmen. Dissidents were confined to their homes or forced to leave Beijing, part of sweeping efforts to prevent online debate or organized commemorations of the anniversary.
________________
And from the June 22 New York Times:
A year and a half after a landmark labor law took effect in China, experts say conditions have actually deteriorated in southern China’s export-oriented factories, which produce many of America’s less expensive retail goods.
With China’s exports reeling and unemployment rising because of the global slowdown, there is growing evidence that factories are ignoring or evading the new law, and that the government is reluctant to enforce it.
Government critics say authorities fear that a crackdown on violators could lead to mass layoffs and even social unrest...
But workers are fighting back. Earlier this month, the government said Chinese courts were trying to cope with a soaring number of labor disputes, apparently from workers emboldened by the promise of the new contract labor law...
The law requires that all employees have a written contract that complies with minimum wage and safety requirements. It also strengthens the monopoly state-run labor union and makes it more difficult for companies to use temporary workers or to dismiss employees.
Western companies that outsource to China say they have stepped up their monitoring of supplier factories to ensure they comply with the law. But they acknowledge that ensuring compliance is challenging in China...
China’s huge and complicated labor market has long thrived on cheap labor and lax regulation. In recent years, labor rights advocates say they have seen incremental gains for workers. But they say there are growing signs of labor abuse...
[F]actory owners say that labor law enforcement has been weak and selective for years, and changing the rules now could lead to chaos, drive up prices and force many factories out of business...
________________
When considering China, what conditions are necessary to claim that rule of law is the effective?
China has the law, but it doesn't appear to have rule of law. What's preventing the effective establishment of rule of law?
When considering Iran, what needs to happen to make it a democracy? Healthy democracies live on more than just elections. Iran is proving this point.
More than a week after Mahmoud Ahmadinejad was re-elected in an apparent landslide, his opponents still continue to protest the election results even as police and security forces try to halt the public displays. More than a dozen protestors have been killed and journalists have been arrested.
All of this exemplifies the complexities of the word democracy.
Iran has called itself an Islamic democracy ever since its revolution in 1979. It gave voting rights to women and even (until recently) to 15-year-olds, and voters directly-elected its legislature and president.
More at CBS 2 School:
//pod08.prospero.com/n/blogs/blog.aspx?webtag=WBBM_school