Breaking News, or Same Old Story? Another ex-Illinois governor was appealing a conviction at the Dirksen Federal Building. What constitutional arguments are Blago's attorneys going to make to try to get the three-judge panel to reverse his conviction?
Blagojevich lawyers to ask for retrial, reduced sentence: The ex-governor's attorneys will ask an appeals court to overturn Blagojevich's corruption convictions, and grant him a whole new trial.
Friday, December 13, 2013
Wednesday, December 11, 2013
Cheers! A toast to Popp (not soda here) Point Leaders
As a teacher of sociology, this linguistic map that popped up a couple of years ago in the NY Times, which tracked where in the country do people call their fizzy drinks, "Soda," "Pop" or "Coke," was of interest to me:
http://ideas.blogs.nytimes.com/2008/09/11/the-soda-vs-pop-map/
Why am I posting this now? Well, later in the second semester we will examine the difficult concept of governing in a country with over 500 languages (Nigeria), but for the here and now it gives a visual that helps me give credit to the Blogging Points leaders as we wind down the first semester.
I call these Popp Points in honor of the student that helped me create the first AP Government Blog (in 2006), WV grad Alex Popp. So here they are the extra credit Popp Point leaders for blogging this first semester (10 pts EC max., "Major Award" for total points winner):
http://ideas.blogs.nytimes.com/2008/09/11/the-soda-vs-pop-map/
Why am I posting this now? Well, later in the second semester we will examine the difficult concept of governing in a country with over 500 languages (Nigeria), but for the here and now it gives a visual that helps me give credit to the Blogging Points leaders as we wind down the first semester.
I call these Popp Points in honor of the student that helped me create the first AP Government Blog (in 2006), WV grad Alex Popp. So here they are the extra credit Popp Point leaders for blogging this first semester (10 pts EC max., "Major Award" for total points winner):
Popp Point (blog posts) Leaders as of 12/12/13:
1. Eric O. -- 8
2. Grant P. -- 5
2. Tara P. (sociology) --5
4. Howie -- 4
4. Ashley Y. (6th hour traditional) -- 4
4. Ashley Y. (6th hour traditional) -- 4
6. Lisa C. -- 3
6. Carly L. -- 3
6. Brendan G -- 3
9. John C. -- 2
9. Anna L. -- 2
9. Claire H. -- 2
9. Katie B. -- 2
9. Kayla A. -- 2
9. Ryan H. -- 2
9. Pei C. -- 2
Others receiving one point: Ester F.; Gloria G.; Bailey Y.; Aamna G.; Remi Y.; James O.; Caitlin F.; Hot Pocket; Scott C.; Brianne S.; Sami B.; Nathan W.; Mahum Z.
EC point opportunity runs out on 1/6/14. This year we have had more postings than last year, when for the first time nobody qualified for maximum Popp Points. So far this year nobody has shown max effort either. So this weekend, make a resolution to pop the lid on your ideas and share them here for points.
Tuesday, December 10, 2013
Holding Court
1) From the 2005 Senate comfirmation hearings of Samuel
Alito, political cartoonist Mike Lane illustrated the constitutional conundrum
facing the newest justice and the term stare decisis -- lettting the precedent
stand unless there are compelling reasons not to -- and a woman's right to
choose an abortion.
Alito's mother said, "Of course he's against
abortion,'' in a classic sound-byte before during the confirmation hearings.
The question is not really what the Alito believes personally, but as NPR
reported in 2005 if that Roe v. Wade was settled law.

2) U.S. Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas made news by speaking his mind, something he's not prone to do while on the job.
As the above data shows, Thomas' silence during Supreme
Court oral arguments is legendary. While his colleagues pepper lawyers with
questions, Thomas listens. While the other 8 justices force legal teams to
perform verbal and logical gymnastics 30 minutes at a time, Thomas often leans
back in his large chair and stares at the ceiling.

"Justice Stevens, the oldest and arguably most liberal justice, now finds
himself the leader of the opposition. Vigorous and sharp at 87, he has served on
the court for 32 years, approaching the record set by his predecessor, William
O. Douglas, who served for 36. In criminal-law and death-penalty cases, Stevens
has voted against the government and in favor of the individual more frequently
than any other sitting justice. He files more dissents and separate opinions
than any of his colleagues. He is the court’s most outspoken defender of the
need for judicial oversight of executive power. And in recent years, he has
written majority opinions in two of the most important cases ruling against the
Bush administration’s treatment of suspected enemy combatants in the war on
terror — an issue the court will revisit this term, which begins Oct. 1, when it
hears appeals by Guantánamo detainees challenging their lack of access to
federal courts."Stevens, however, is an improbable liberal icon. “I don’t think of myself as a liberal at all,” he told me during a recent interview in his chambers, laughing and shaking his head. “I think as part of my general politics, I’m pretty darn conservative.”
http://www.nytimes.com/2007/09/23/magazine/23stevens-t.html?_r=1&oref=slogin
This is one of the two linked articles you need to read and comment on by Monday.
This is one of the two linked articles you need to read and comment on by Monday.
4) The second article you need to have read by Tuesday is Time's cover story from October, 2007:
The Incredible Shrinking Court
"The irony is that the Court's ideology is playing a dwindling role in the lives
of Americans. The familiar hot-button controversies--abortion, affirmative
action, the death penalty, police powers and so on--have been around so long,
sifted and resifted so many times, that they now arrive at the court in highly
specific cases affecting few, if any, real people. And it's not clear that
Roberts wants to alter that trend. His speeches on the judicial role suggest a
man more interested in the steady retreat of the court from public policy than
in a right-wing revolution. Unless the Roberts court umpires another disputed
presidential election (à la Bush v. Gore in 2000--a long shot, to say the
least), the left-right division will matter mainly in the realm of theories and
rhetoric, dear to the hearts of law professors and political activists but
remote from day-to-day existence. What once was salient is now mostly
symbolic."READ MORE
5) SCOTUSblog STAT PACK
Probably way more statistics on The Supremes, but if you are doing this assingment option, filter through the Stat Pack and share the three (3) biggest takeaways that you get from the numbers about our current Supreme Court. Why are these stats interesting to you?
6) Finally, a re-run post from 2009's 'Global Warming' SC
decision:
The world saw former Vice-President being called a “rock star” and getting an Oscar from movie stars for his documentary on the “climate crisis,” and later a Nobel Peace Prize. But with far less glitz and fanfare, the legal definition of whether global warming is damaging US and the world was being argued in the U.S. Supreme Court a few months ago.
The new “swing vote” on the high Court is Justice Anthony Kennedy and his questions during the oral arguments in Massachusetts, et al. v. EPA (05-1120) seemed to indicate that justices may be ready to decide more than the case at bar.
At issue is the states’ (MA. and 12 others, including Illinois) lawsuit challenging the federal bureaucracy’s (EPA) lack of enforcement of an act of Congress (1990 Clean Air Act). The questions the Court is considering are:1) May the EPA decline to issue emission standards for motor vehicles based on policy considerations not enumerated in the Clean Air Act?2) Does the Clean Air Act give the EPA authority to regulate carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases?Breaking down the oral argument, Justice Kennedy seemed to be saying the Court has a bigger, global, question to answer. But not all on the bench seemed to think it was in the Court’s jurisdiction.
From the transcript of the oral argument, Justice Kennedy is questioning counsel for the petitioners, the Massachusetts states attorney:
JUSTICE KENNEDY: At the outset, you made this, some of this perhaps reassuring statement that we need not decide about global warming in this case. But don't we have to do that in order to decide the standing argument, because there's no injury if there's not global warming? Or, can you show standing simply because there is a likelihood that the perceived would show that there's an injury?
MR. MILKEY: Your Honor, especially in this case where none of our affidavits were challenged, I don't think the Court needs to go there ultimately on the merits because we showed through our uncontested affidavits that these harms will occur. There was no evidence put in to the contrary, and I would add that the reports on which EPA itself relies conclude that climate change is occurring.
JUSTICE KENNEDY (later): What is the scientific answer to if global warming exists? I think this Court might have to press for an answer to this question.
(Justice Antonin Scalia’s prides himself as a strict constructionalist, and a Constitutional scholar. He never claimed to have aced Mr. Rosiano’s “Cosmic Journey” class, he chimes in):
JUSTICE SCALIA: Mr. Milkey, I always thought an air pollutant was something different from a stratospheric pollutant, and your claim here is not that the pollution of what we normally call "air" is endangering health. That isn't, that isn't -- your assertion is that after the pollutant leaves the air and goes up into the stratosphere it is contributing to global warming.
MR. MILKEY: Respectfully, Your Honor, it is not the stratosphere. It's the troposphere.
JUSTICE SCALIA: Troposphere, whatever. I told you before I'm not a scientist. (Laughter.)
JUSTICE SCALIA: That's why I don't want to have to deal with global warming, to tell you the truth.The decision in Massachusetts, et al. v. EPA (05-1120), given last June ruled in favor of Massachusetts.
The world saw former Vice-President being called a “rock star” and getting an Oscar from movie stars for his documentary on the “climate crisis,” and later a Nobel Peace Prize. But with far less glitz and fanfare, the legal definition of whether global warming is damaging US and the world was being argued in the U.S. Supreme Court a few months ago.
The new “swing vote” on the high Court is Justice Anthony Kennedy and his questions during the oral arguments in Massachusetts, et al. v. EPA (05-1120) seemed to indicate that justices may be ready to decide more than the case at bar.
At issue is the states’ (MA. and 12 others, including Illinois) lawsuit challenging the federal bureaucracy’s (EPA) lack of enforcement of an act of Congress (1990 Clean Air Act). The questions the Court is considering are:1) May the EPA decline to issue emission standards for motor vehicles based on policy considerations not enumerated in the Clean Air Act?2) Does the Clean Air Act give the EPA authority to regulate carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases?Breaking down the oral argument, Justice Kennedy seemed to be saying the Court has a bigger, global, question to answer. But not all on the bench seemed to think it was in the Court’s jurisdiction.
From the transcript of the oral argument, Justice Kennedy is questioning counsel for the petitioners, the Massachusetts states attorney:
JUSTICE KENNEDY: At the outset, you made this, some of this perhaps reassuring statement that we need not decide about global warming in this case. But don't we have to do that in order to decide the standing argument, because there's no injury if there's not global warming? Or, can you show standing simply because there is a likelihood that the perceived would show that there's an injury?
MR. MILKEY: Your Honor, especially in this case where none of our affidavits were challenged, I don't think the Court needs to go there ultimately on the merits because we showed through our uncontested affidavits that these harms will occur. There was no evidence put in to the contrary, and I would add that the reports on which EPA itself relies conclude that climate change is occurring.
JUSTICE KENNEDY (later): What is the scientific answer to if global warming exists? I think this Court might have to press for an answer to this question.
(Justice Antonin Scalia’s prides himself as a strict constructionalist, and a Constitutional scholar. He never claimed to have aced Mr. Rosiano’s “Cosmic Journey” class, he chimes in):
JUSTICE SCALIA: Mr. Milkey, I always thought an air pollutant was something different from a stratospheric pollutant, and your claim here is not that the pollution of what we normally call "air" is endangering health. That isn't, that isn't -- your assertion is that after the pollutant leaves the air and goes up into the stratosphere it is contributing to global warming.
MR. MILKEY: Respectfully, Your Honor, it is not the stratosphere. It's the troposphere.
JUSTICE SCALIA: Troposphere, whatever. I told you before I'm not a scientist. (Laughter.)
JUSTICE SCALIA: That's why I don't want to have to deal with global warming, to tell you the truth.The decision in Massachusetts, et al. v. EPA (05-1120), given last June ruled in favor of Massachusetts.
Friday, December 6, 2013
Nelson Mandela (1918-2013)
(From PBS.org)
He united a nation and inspired the world.
In the wake of Nelson Mandela's passing, we've made FRONTLINE's The Long Walk of Nelson Mandela available to watch online for the very first time.
In The Long Walk of Nelson Mandela, FRONTLINE tells the intimate and surprising story of the Nelson Mandela few people know: a bomb-throwing revolutionary who became a skilled politician in prison, and a passionate man who sacrificed the love of his life for a country that needed him more.
Watch and blog, what YOU and YOUR GOVERNMENT LEADERS can learn from Nelson Mandela.
Viewers & Teachers Guide
Friday, November 29, 2013
Presidential Cabinet vs. White House Staff
Thursday, November 28, 2013
JFK, Obamacare and Separation of Church and State
Above, Senator John F. Kennedy as he was running for president spoke to Texas ministers on our tradition of a "Wall of Separation" between Church and State. It's a theme we revisit again this week, as the Supremes announced they have issued a Writ of Certiori to hear another judicial challenge to the Affordable Health Care Act on the grounds it violates the religious freedoms of for-profit secular companies that don't want to cover birth control in their health insurance offerings.
From the NY Times:
WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court on Tuesday agreed to hear a pair of cases on whether corporations may refuse to provide insurance coverage for contraception to their workers based on the religious beliefs of the corporations’ owners.
The cases present a new challenge to President Obama’s health care law. The Supreme Court in 2012 upheld another part of the law, one that requires most Americans to obtain health insurance or pay a penalty.
The Obama administration has exempted many religious groups from the law’s requirements for contraception coverage. But it said that commercial corporations could not rely on religious objections to opt out of compliance with the law.
“Our policy is designed to ensure that health care decisions are made between a woman and her doctor,” Jay Carney, the White House press secretary, said in a statement. “The president believes that no one, including the government or for-profit corporations, should be able to dictate those decisions to women.”
__________________________
Blog here, your thoughts on the "Wall of Separation" in American Society. BTW, I am thankful when students post on Political Warrior. You will be thankful, too with 10 points of EC at the end of the semester.
President's Pardon Power: Thanksgiving, Presidential Tradition met by PETA protest
(From White House.gov)
We've come a long way since 11-year-old Tad Lincoln convinced his father to "adopt" a turkey named Jack in 1863.
Today, President Obama pardoned two 20-week-old, 38-pound turkeys named Popcorn and Caramel -- and announced Popcorn as the official "National Thanksgiving Turkey," after the American public weighed in on their favorites via Twitter, Facebook, and Instagram.
The President noted:
The competition was stiff, but we can officially declare that Popcorn is the winner -- proving that even a turkey with a funny name can find a place in politics. As for Caramel, he’s sticking around, and he’s already busy raising money for his next campaign.
And so, all "Hunger Games" references aside, both turkeys will live. Popcorn and Caramel will spend the rest of their natural days in the historic rolling pastures of Morven Park's Turkey Hill -- located at the home of former Virginia governor Westmoreland Davis in Leesburg, Virginia.
Depending on whom you ask, President Abraham Lincoln was the first to spare a turkey, when his son Tad "adopted" the bird intended for Christmas dinner and named it Jack. As President Clinton noted in a speech in 1997, "President Lincoln had no choice but to give Jack the full run of the White House."
The official annual presentation of a Thanksgiving turkey began under President Harry Truman, but there wouldn't be any official "pardoning" for several decades. According to his presidential library's documents, President Eisenhower, too, appears to have eaten the birds presented to him over the course of his two terms in office.
President Kennedy sent a particularly scrawny turkey back to the farm in 1963, saying "we'll let this one grow." (Not quite the stuff of empathetic pardons.)
It was President Ronald Reagan that issued the first "pardon" on record, when he was presented with a turkey named Charlie in 1987 -- Charlie was thereby sent to a petting zoo -- and President George H.W. Bush made the turkey pardon a permanent fixture in the American presidency.
Since then, pardoned turkeys have been sent to a variety of pastoral American venues -- from Frying Pan Park in Fairfax, Virginia, to the Disneyland Resort in California to Mount Vernon -- the home and estate of President George Washington.
As the President said today, "The Office of the Presidency -- the most powerful position in the world -- brings with it many awesome and solemn responsibilities. This is not one of them."
Popcorn and Caramel might disagree.
____________________
And maybe further evidence of the complexities of criticism of a modern president, Obama's pardon was met by a special interest protest posted on YouTube by PETA:
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)



